HKU POP SITE releases the latest results of survey on constitutional reformBack


Press Release on December 14, 2005
 

In order to gauge people's views towards universal suffrage and the government's constitutional reform package, the Public Opinion Programme (POP) at the University of Hong Kong has conducted two rounds of surveys on constitutional reform before and after the December 4 Rally using the same set of questions. The first survey was conducted before the rally and sponsored by the Apple Daily, while the second one was conducted after the rally and sponsored by the National Democratic Institute for International Affairs (NDI). For both surveys, POP was fully responsible for designing the survey and conducting the fieldwork, quality control, data analysis and press release compilation, without any interference from the client. The results of the first survey have already been released via the Apple Daily and the "HKU POP SITE". This press release carries the latest results of the second survey sponsored by NDI, and compares them with those of the first survey. For detailed results, please refer to the "HKU POP SITE".

 

Both surveys were conducted by telephone interviewers, and the target population was Cantonese-speaking population of Hong Kong aged 18 or above. As a general practice, all figures have been weighted according to the gender-age distribution of the Hong Kong population obtained from the 2001 Population Census.

 
    First survey   Second survey 
  Date of survey  30/11-1/12   9-12/12 
  Sample base  514   511 
  Overall response rate  64.7%   70.7% 
  Sampling error of percentages(at 95% confidence level)*  +/- 4%   +/- 4% 
  The government's recent reform package mainly proposes to increase the number of Election Committee members from 800 to 1600 and to include all elected and appointed District Council members into the Committee, it also proposes to increase the number of Legco seats from 60 to 70, with 5 of the new seats to be returned by direct election, and the other 5 to be returned through election by all elected and appointed District Council members from among themselves. Do you support this proposal?
  Yes  44%   43% 
  Neutral / Half-half  16%   15% 
  No  17%   16% 
  Don't know / Hard to say  22%   25% 
  Total  100%   100% 
  Some Legco members have demanded the inclusion of timetable for universal suffrage in the reform package. Do you support this demand?
  Yes  52%   52% 
  Neutral / Half-half  13%   13% 
  No  21%   19% 
  Don't know / Hard to say  13%   16% 
  Total  100%   100% 
  Some Legco members said if the government refused to include the timetable for universal suffrage in the reform package, they would vote against it. Do you support the move of these Legco members?
  Yes  29%   25% 
  Neutral / Half-half  10%   14% 
  No  47%   47% 
  Don't know / Hard to say  14%   14% 
  Total  100%   100% 
 Basic Law Article 45 stipulates that the Chief Executive should ultimately be returned by universal suffrage "in the light of the actual situation in the Hong Kong… and in accordance with the principle of gradual and orderly progress." By which year do you think this target could be achieved? 
    Percentage   Cumulative percentage   Percentage   Cumulative percentage 
 Sooner the better   7%   7%   10%   10% 
 In or before 2007 (the next CE should be elected in 2007)   19%   27%   19%   29% 
 Between 2008 and 2012 (the next next CE should be elected in 2012)   35%   61%   30%   58% 
 Between 2013 and 2017 (another CE to follow)   11%   72%   8%   66% 
 Between 2018 and 2022 (another CE to follow)   1%   74%   2%   68% 
 In or after 2023   1%   75%   2%   70% 
 Don't know / Hard to say   25%   100%   30%   100% 
 Total   100%      100%    
 Basic Law Article 68 stipulates that all members of LegCo should ultimately be returned by universal suffrage "in the light of the actual situation… and in accordance with the principle of gradual and orderly progress." By which year do you think this target could be achieved? 
    Percentage   Cumulative percentage   Percentage   Cumulative percentage 
 Sooner the better   9%   9%   11%   11% 
 In or before 2008 (the next Legco should begin in 2008)   27%   37%   27%   38% 
 Between 2009 and 2012 (the next next Legco should begin in 2012)   26%   63%   22%   61% 
 Between 2013 and 2016 (another Legco to follow)   7%   70%   7%   68% 
 Between 2017 and 2020 (another Legco to follow)   1%   71%   2%   69% 
 In or after 2021   2%   72%   1%   70% 
 Don't know / Hard to say   28%   100%   30%   100% 
 Total   100%      100%    

* "95% confidence level" means that if we were to repeat a certain survey 100 times, using the same questions each time but with different random samples, we would expect 95 times getting a figure within the error margins specified.

 

According to the latest survey conducted from 9 to 12 December, 43% of the respondents supported the government's constitutional reform package. However, 52% thought the government should include a timetable for universal suffrage in the reform package. While some Legislative Council members said they would vote against the reform package if the government refused to include the timetable, 47% would not support such a move whereas 25% said they would. Concerning the universal suffrage of the Chief Executive and the Legislative Council, 29% and 38% respectively thought they should be achieved by the next session, while 58% and 61% said they should be achieved In or before 2012.

 

Robert Ting-Yiu Chung, Director of Public Opinion Programme, analyzed, "Comparing the results of the two rounds of surveys, it is found that the people's views towards the reform package before and after the December 4 Rally have remained practically unchanged, meaning that public opinion is very stable. In both surveys, nearly 45% found the government's reform package acceptable, but over half demanded the inclusion of timetable for universal suffrage in the reform package. Nevertheless, if the government insists on not including it, only less than 30% would like to see the package voted down. In other words, people accepts a package without timetable, but it would become a win-win situation if a timetable could be included."

 

Robert Chung also observed, "During our latest survey, 25 respondents said they had taken part in the December 4 Rally. As expected, the vast majority of them demanded that universal suffrage should be achieved before 2012, and would like to see the inclusion of timetable for universal suffrage in the reform package. However, about one-fifth of them also supported the government's package, and would not like to see the package voted down due to its lack of timetable for universal suffrage. In other words, not all December 4 Rally participants are completely against the government's proposal, but for the sake of promoting consensus in society, the government should also make some appropriate concessions."

 

Shall anyone have any question regarding the research design of the surveys published in the POP Site, members of the POP Team will be happy to answer them, but we will not further comment on the findings. Shall any person or journalist have any other questions, please email them to us at <[email protected]>. The Director of Public Opinion Programme would answer them as soon as possible. We will keep such an arrangement under constant review, suggestions most welcome. Please note that everything carried in the POP Site does not represent the stand of the University of Hong Kong. Dr Robert Ting-Yiu Chung, Director of Public Opinion Programme, is responsible for everything posted herewith, except for column articles which represent the stand of their authors.